SEO consultant, agency or do it yourself?
What each option does, how you pay for it, and how to tell which one your business needs, checked against Google's own advice on hiring an SEO.
If you run a small local business, you can probably do much of your own SEO: Google says so itself. Hire an SEO consultant when you need an expert to find what’s holding your site back and put the fixes in order. Choose an agency when you need a team doing the work every month. Before you pay for monthly work, start with a fixed-price audit; whoever you hire, keep ownership of your Google accounts, and walk away from anyone who guarantees a ranking.
We sell SEO ourselves, so where Google’s advice on whether you need an SEO covers a point, we follow it and say so. Where it doesn’t, as on how consultants and agencies differ, the view is ours.
The three options side by side
Google lists the same services for consultants and agencies. What differs is who does the work, and how you pay for it.
| Do it yourself | SEO consultant | SEO agency | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Suits | A small local business with a few hours a month | A diagnosis, a plan or a second opinion | Steady monthly work: content, local SEO, links and reports |
| Who does the work | You or your staff | One specialist, who may advise, do the work, or both | A team |
| What you pay | Your time: Search Console and a Business Profile are free | A fee per hour, per job or per month | A monthly fee; ask about the minimum term |
| What to ask | Will I keep at it, month after month? | Who will make the changes on my site? | Who will actually do my work? |
When is doing it yourself enough?
When you run a small local business, have a few hours a month to give it, and your site has no hidden technical problems. Google’s advice on whether you need an SEO says a small local business can probably do much of the work itself, starting with its SEO Starter Guide.
The first steps cost nothing but time. Set up Search Console, Google’s free service for monitoring your site’s presence in its results. If customers visit you or you travel to them, claim your free Google Business Profile: Google’s Business Profile guidelines set that condition. Then give each service its own page, and ask every customer for a review.
Every Business and Professional website we build comes with Search Console and Google Analytics 4 set up, and a Google Business Profile if your business qualifies for one, so owners who do their own SEO start with the tools in place.
Doing it yourself stops being enough when the problem is one you can’t see: pages Google won’t index, a slow site, or spam a hacker has placed on it. That is where help is worth paying for.
When should you hire an SEO consultant?
When you need expert judgement more than extra hands: to find what’s holding your site back, to put the fixes in order, or to check a plan someone else is selling you. It works best when you, your staff or your web developer can make the changes the consultant recommends.
An SEO consultant is usually a single specialist, freelance or in a small practice. Google says a great time to hire is when you’re planning a redesign (“the earlier, the better”) or a new site, so the site is search-friendly from the start.
The limit is capacity. One person has only so many hours, and a report changes nothing until someone acts on it.
When does an agency make sense?
When you need steady work every month at a volume one person can’t cover: new content, local SEO, links and reporting, for a large site, several branches or a crowded market. You’re paying for a team, so expect a monthly commitment, and ask who will actually do your work.
The trade-off is distance: you may deal with an account manager rather than the specialist. Ask whether any of the work is outsourced, and how they’ll report to you. Google also reminds owners that they’re responsible for the actions of any company they hire.
Who will make the changes?
Whoever can change your website. An audit or a plan is only a list until someone rewrites pages, fixes redirects, speeds the site up or cleans out spam. If your SEO only advises, the work passes to your web developer, and each fix waits on a second supplier. Settle who does it before you hire anyone.
Some problems can only be fixed on the site itself. Xscape4u was referred to us after a compromise: its site was being injected with links to offshore casino sites. No amount of advice fixes that. We rebuilt the platform and delivered it clean, protected with encryption and the Wordfence security plugin.
We build and host WordPress websites as well as doing SEO, so if we build or host your site, the fixes an audit turns up can be made by the same studio, quoted per task before we start. Fyre is a one-person business, so you deal directly with the person doing the work. Thrive Raw Food For Dogs, an online store we built in 2025, has hosting, SEO and Google Ads in its ongoing work with us. We also host the site of Financial Crime Risk Management Consultants, a client since 2009.
Before you hire anyone
Consultant or agency, Google’s advice on hiring an SEO is to interview them first: ask to see previous work and results, ask whether they’ll share every change they make and why, and find someone else if they guarantee first place. How to choose an SEO company turns that advice into questions to ask, and our guide to what SEO costs in South Africa lists Google’s warning signs.
Keep your analytics, Search Console and Business Profile in your own name, and give your SEO access, not ownership. Our audit reads your Search Console data through read-only access, which is what the same Google page advises for an audit. Then changing supplier takes an email, not a rescue. The section on keeping the keys in your name, in what SEO costs in South Africa, sets out Google’s rules for Search Console and the Business Profile.
Start with an audit, not a contract
When the free steps stop being enough, and before you commit to monthly work, start with an audit: it shows what’s wrong and what to fix first. Ours costs R6,500 incl. VAT and covers technical, on-page, local and competitor checks, ending in a prioritised fix list. It takes about a week, and is scheduled into the calendar when it is booked. It stands on its own: buying it doesn’t commit you to a retainer. If you start one within 30 days, half the fee is credited against the first month. The retainer is from R7,500 a month incl. VAT, with a six-month minimum, and covers content, on-page and local work, link acquisition and monthly reporting. After the six-month minimum it runs month to month, with one calendar month’s notice. See a sample audit report (a fictional example).
Making the fixes isn’t part of the audit. Do them yourself, give the list to your developer or a consultant, or ask us to quote per task before we start. For what shapes SEO prices, see what SEO costs in South Africa; for how we work, see our SEO Johannesburg page.
Book an SEO audit. We reply to new enquiries on the same business day.
Frequently asked questions
What does a SEO consultant do?
An SEO consultant finds out what stops your website being found on Google, and what to change. Google’s page Do you need an SEO? lists services that SEOs, agencies and consultants offer, including reviewing a site’s content or structure, technical advice on hosting, redirects and error pages, content development, keyword research and SEO training. Some consultants make the changes themselves; others advise and leave the work to you or your developer.
How much does an SEO consultant cost?
It depends on how they charge: by the hour, by the job or by the month. Ask for a fixed price for a defined piece of work, such as an audit, so you know the cost before you start. Our prices are published: an SEO audit is R6,500, and our retainer is from R7,500 a month with a six-month minimum, both incl. VAT.
Can I do SEO on my own?
Much of it, if you run a small local business: Google says you can probably do much of the work yourself. Even if you later hire someone, it suggests learning the basics from its SEO Starter Guide, so you’ll notice if an SEO wants to use a technique Google discourages. Get help when the problems are technical, or when you can’t tell which fix comes first.
Is SEO difficult to learn?
The basics aren’t. Google’s SEO Starter Guide walks through some of the most common and effective improvements you can make to your site, and says it holds no secrets that will automatically rank a site first. What takes experience is diagnosis: why pages aren’t indexed, why a site is slow, which fix matters most. Results take patience too: Google says some changes can take several months.
