How to choose the best SEO company: the questions that separate good from bad
Nine questions to put to every SEO company on your shortlist, what a good answer and a warning sign sound like, and how to check the claims before you sign.
The best SEO company for your business isn’t the one with the boldest promise. It’s the one that looks at your website before it quotes, tells you what it will change and why, never guarantees first place on Google, and leaves you owning everything it sets up. To find it, put the same questions to every company on your shortlist and check the answers. Here are the questions, what good and bad answers sound like, and how to test the claims you’ll hear.
How do you tell a good SEO company from a bad one?
By how honest it is about what it controls. A good one studies your business and your site before it quotes, explains each change in plain words, measures success in enquiries, not rankings alone, and never promises first place. A bad one sells certainty, keeps its methods secret and leaves you owning nothing.
Google publishes its own advice on hiring an SEO, and this article uses it as the benchmark. It says to check whether a company is interested in you and your business: a good one asks what makes your business unique, who your competitors are, how search results can help and how your customers find you. If it isn’t interested, Google says, find someone who is. So notice what a company asks you in the first meeting, as well as what it tells you.
Which questions should you ask an SEO company?
Nine questions cover it: what they’ll do first, whether they guarantee rankings, what work you can check, how they measure success, whether they’ll explain each change, where links will come from, who owns the accounts, what they’ll do about AI search, and who fixes what they find. Listen for plain, specific answers.
| Ask | A good answer | A warning sign |
|---|---|---|
| What will you do first? | Audit your site at an agreed price, and give you a prioritised list of fixes | A monthly package quoted before anyone has looked at your site |
| Can you guarantee first place on Google? | No, and a clear account of what they can influence | Yes, or a ranking promised by a date |
| Can I see your work, and speak to a client? | Named clients, live sites you can visit, and a reference you can call | Every client is confidential, or the only proof is a ranking screenshot |
| How will you measure success? | Enquiries and sales from search, with Search Console’s clicks and impressions, reported monthly | Rankings for phrases nobody searches for |
| Will you explain every change? | Yes, in writing, with the reason, and Google’s own documentation where it applies | Methods described as secret or proprietary |
| Where will the links come from? | Earned from suppliers, associations, the press and pages worth linking to | Link packages, link swaps or mass directory submissions |
| Who will own the accounts? | You, with the company added as a user you can remove | Accounts opened in the agency’s name |
| What will you do about AI search? | The same groundwork as for search, because Google treats it as SEO | Special AI files or tricks sold as essential |
| Who fixes what the audit finds? | They do, or they agree with your developer who does what | A long report and nobody to act on it |
Most of these come from Google’s own advice on hiring an SEO, whose list of questions also asks how long a company has been in business and what experience it has in your industry and in your country or city. Three rows need a word more.
Ownership. Keep your Search Console property and, if you have one, your Google Business Profile in your name, and add the company as a user or manager. Google’s rules for both accounts, with links to its help pages, are in the section on keeping the keys in what SEO costs in South Africa, and what you should get for it, and Business Profile owners, managers and who should hold the keys goes further.
Links. Google’s spam policies list excessive link exchanges, automated link-building services and low-quality directory links as link spam, alongside buying links for ranking purposes: the swaps, packages and mass submissions in the table.
AI search. Google’s guide to its generative AI features says optimising for them is still SEO, and that Google Search ignores special AI text files such as llms.txt. See how to get your business cited in AI search.
You can check some of our own answers now. We’ve built websites since 2001, our prices are published, and our SEO clients include Thrive Raw Food For Dogs, on our work page with a link to its live site.
A few more answers, in plain terms. Our audit reads your Search Console data through read-only access. Our link work starts with free routes, and we use paid placements only when free work can’t close the gap, and only sponsored articles marked as sponsored, relevant directory listings, memberships and real sponsorships; we never use link sellers, private blog networks or paid guest posts. Our monthly report shows what went live since the last one, real numbers against your baseline, the same searches repeated by area and device, new referring domains checked for spam, what is working, what isn’t yet, and what to do next.
How can you check what an SEO company claims?
Trust what you can check yourself: client websites you can visit, clients you can call, and Search Console figures a client has agreed to share. Be sceptical of what you can’t check: ranking screenshots, badges that measure something else, tools said to be approved by Google, and lists of the best agencies published by agencies.
Here is how to read the common ones, using Google’s own pages.
- Ranking screenshots. A screenshot shows one search, from one place, at one moment. Google’s help page on the Search Console Performance report says search results are specific to the time, place, device and recent history of the person searching, and the report counts the clicks and impressions of real searches. Ask for those figures instead.
- Badges. A Google Partner badge is about advertising. Google’s requirements for Partner status are a minimum optimisation score on the company’s Google Ads manager account, ad spend across the accounts it manages, and Google Ads certifications, and Google’s advice on hiring an SEO says advertising with Google has no effect on your site’s presence in its search results. The same page warns against anyone who claims a “special relationship” with Google.
- Tools. The same page says Google doesn’t evaluate or endorse third-party SEO tools, and that they have no access to its internal ranking data, so be wary of any tool presented as approved by Google.
- Lists. When we checked Google’s South African results for “best seo company” on 27 September 2026, every list of top SEO agencies on the first page came from an agency or a directory of agencies, and one agency’s list put its own name first. A list is somewhere to start, not a verdict.
- References. Google’s advice on hiring an SEO also suggests asking past clients whether the company was useful, easy to work with and produced positive results. A named client with a live website is a claim you can test in a minute.
Google’s warning signs, from guaranteed rankings to bought links, and why their consequences land on you, are listed in our guide to what SEO costs in South Africa, and what you should get for it.
What should a good SEO company do first?
The first job should be an audit: how search engines read your site, how well each page matches what customers search for, how you appear in local results and who you’re up against. Google’s advice on hiring an SEO says an audit should give realistic estimates of improvement and of the work involved.
Our SEO audit is a fixed R6,500 incl. VAT. It covers four areas: technical, on-page, local and competitors. It ends in one prioritised fix list, most important first, with an estimate of the work involved in each fix, so you can see what to do now and what can wait. Making the fixes isn’t part of the audit: do them yourself, hand the list to your developer, or ask us to quote each task before we start. If we build or host your site as well, the technical fixes don’t have to pass between two suppliers. See a sample audit report (a fictional example).
If you start a monthly retainer within 30 days, half the audit fee is credited against the first month. What a proper SEO audit covers explains what a good audit should include, and our SEO Johannesburg page sets out the audit and the retainer in full.
Book an SEO audit. Send us your website’s address and we’ll reply the same business day.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best SEO company in South Africa?
There isn’t one for every business, only the company that answers the questions above best for yours. Be careful with the map near the top of Google’s results, too. Google’s guide to local ranking says local results are mainly based on relevance, distance and popularity, and that there’s no way to pay for a better local ranking. The agencies you see partly reflect where you are searching from.
Which is the best company for SEO services?
The best SEO service is the one whose answers hold up when you check them: an audit before any monthly fee, no promised rankings, every change explained in writing, the accounts left in your name, and a clear answer on who makes the fixes. Put the same questions to every company on your shortlist. We compare a consultant, an agency and doing it yourself separately.
How much is SEO for a small business?
With us, an SEO audit costs R6,500 and monthly SEO starts from R7,500 a month with a six-month minimum, both incl. VAT. Starting with the audit tells you what is worth paying for before you commit to a monthly fee. What SEO costs in South Africa, and what you should get for it sets out what each fee should buy, and what low-cost SEO offers really buy covers prices that look too good.
