Loyalty card program software: an off-the-shelf app or a custom platform?
Rent an app when a standard programme is enough. Have a platform built when the programme needs its own rules, its own connections or other companies' names on it. Here is how to tell which one you are.
Rent an off-the-shelf app if a standard points or stamp programme covers what you need. Have a platform built only when the programme needs rules, connections or branding that no app offers. Most businesses should start by renting.
Search for “loyalty card program software” and almost every result is a vendor describing its own product. This article compares the routes instead, and ends with the questions to put to whoever sells you one.
The reward, the rules and what they cost you come before the software. Our guide to running a loyalty programme in South Africa takes them in order.
What kinds of loyalty software can a business choose from?
There are four routes to running a loyalty card program. You can rent an app at your till, rent a digital stamp card that sits in the customer’s phone wallet, add a points extension to your own online store, or have a platform built for you. The first three are ready-made. The fourth costs far more to start.
| App at the till | Digital stamp card | Extension on your store | Custom platform | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Example | Yoco Loyalty | Loopy Loyalty | WooCommerce Points and Rewards | Built by a developer, such as Fyre |
| Where it works | On Yoco’s own hardware | In Apple Wallet and Google Wallet, stamped by staff with an app | In a WooCommerce store, at the cart and checkout | Wherever the build is scoped to work |
| How the customer is known | Cell number, entered once at the card machine | A card saved to the phone’s wallet | A customer account on the store | Your choice |
| How you pay | Included in the Plus plan at R249 a month | From US$25 a month on the Starter plan, or a yearly plan | US$179 for a 1-year plan, or a 2-year plan | From R65,000 incl. VAT, quoted after a free first discovery |
| Limits the vendor states | No per-customer reporting; minimum spend threshold fixed at setup; needs an internet connection | Starter plan: 1 card design and 1 location | Guest checkout earns no points; no built-in export | Set by the scope agreed in discovery |
What does an off-the-shelf loyalty app do well, and where does it stop?
A rented app does the common things well: it signs customers up quickly, records what they earn as part of the sale, and the vendor keeps it running. It stops where the vendor’s design stops. You get the rules, the reports and the limits the product has, and you cannot add your own.
At the till. Yoco’s Loyalty page says there is no separate fee and no per-customer cost beyond the Plus plan, and that every card payment earns points automatically, so staff have nothing extra to do. The page is also open about its limits, which are in the table above. The hardware it lists is all Yoco’s own, and it says nothing about sales on a website.
In the phone’s wallet. Loopy Loyalty is a digital loyalty card system built on stamps. The customer saves it to Apple Wallet or Google Wallet, and your staff add stamps with an app. Loopy Loyalty’s pricing page sizes its plans by card designs, locations and staff users, so a second branch can mean a bigger plan.
When is a loyalty extension on your own online store enough?
It is enough when your customers buy online, hold accounts on your store, and the reward is a discount on a later order. An extension adds points to the store you already run, so earning and redeeming happen in the checkout your customers know.
WooCommerce Points and Rewards is an example, sold by Woo itself. Woo’s Points and Rewards page describes what you control:
- how many points a purchase earns, for the whole store, a category or a single product;
- what points are worth as a discount, and the largest discount they can cover;
- whether points expire;
- manual changes to a customer’s balance, with every change logged.
The same page lists the conditions. Points are tied to customer accounts, so a guest checkout earns nothing. The extension has no export of its own: a separate add-on exports the points data. The page says nothing about sales at a shop counter.
When is a custom loyalty platform worth the cost?
It is worth it when the programme is part of how the business earns its money, and a rented product would force you to change the programme to fit the software. If the rules are ordinary, a build buys you nothing a subscription does not.
Our guide to running a loyalty programme in South Africa lists the five cases a standard app does not cover. Test yours the same way each time: put the rule to the vendor in writing, and build only if the answer is no. One case stands apart: other companies running the programme under their own names. None of the vendor pages in the table mentions it.
That is the clearest case for a build. We built over 50 white-label rewards platforms for One Loyalty, a client since 2006, which it used to provide third-party assist services to its insurance clients. Those platforms are no longer in use. The One Loyalty case study tells the rest.
Our price for this work is from R65,000 incl. VAT, quoted only. The first discovery and quote are free; if you go ahead, the build starts with detailed scoping, included in the price. Our business systems page explains how that works.
A built platform also has to be hosted and kept up to date. Ask for those costs with the quote.
What goes wrong as a loyalty programme grows?
Four things tend to go wrong: the reports stop answering your questions, a rule you need cannot be changed, the shop and the website keep separate balances, and leaving turns out to be harder than joining. The questions in the next section check for each.
Reports. Totals are enough at the start. Later you will want to know which members came back and which stopped, and only a record per member shows that.
Rules. A setting fixed when you switch the programme on stays fixed. A minimum spend that suited your first members remains, whether or not it still suits the business.
Two balances. An app at the till and an extension on the website are two programmes. A customer who buys both ways will have two balances.
Leaving. Loopy Loyalty’s pricing page says that when you cancel, your account and all its loyalty cards are scheduled for deletion once the billing period ends. Your members’ stamps exist only while you pay, so know how you would take the list with you.
Built software ages too. GiftBucks, a client since 2003, had a platform whose original code could no longer be maintained, and we rebuilt it as a custom WordPress plugin with current security. The account is in one gift-card platform since 2007.
Which questions should you put to a loyalty software vendor?
Ask about money, limits, your data and the exit, and ask for the answers in writing. A vendor’s sales page tells you what the product does. These questions find out what it does not do, and what happens on the day you want to change something or leave. Send them before you sign up.
To any vendor of a rented product:
- What does it cost a month, in which currency, and what makes the price go up: members, branches, staff users or card designs?
- Which rules can I change after launch, and which are fixed at setup?
- Can I see each member’s history, or only totals?
- Does it work on my till, on my website, or both, with one balance?
- What happens at the counter when the internet connection is down?
- Can I export my members and their balances, in what format, and on which plan?
- If I cancel, how long is my data kept, and what do my members see?
- If a member changes cell number or loses a phone, how is the balance moved?
To anyone quoting to build one:
- Is there a separate scoping phase, what does it produce, and is it priced on its own or included in the build?
- Who owns the code, and what does my licence allow?
- Who hosts it, who updates it, and what does that cost a month?
- How are changes quoted after launch?
- Which systems like this have you built, and are they still running?
Our own answer to the second question: custom code we write stays our copyright and you are licensed to use it on your own site, unless we agree in writing, before the work starts, that you own it outright.
The next step
Write down your rules first, then test them against the table. If a rented app or an extension carries them, use it. If your rules, your systems or your clients’ brands rule out a rented product, our custom business systems page shows how we scope and build a platform.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best software for managing a loyalty program?
There is no single best product, because the right one depends on where you sell. A shop that takes card payments is served by an app on its card machine. An online store is served by a points extension in its checkout. A programme with its own rules, or one run under other companies’ names, needs a platform built for it.
What is the best loyalty program app?
For most small businesses, it is the one that asks least of the customer. Yoco’s Loyalty page, for example, says customers enter their phone number once at the card machine, and can check their balance with no app download and no login. An app that customers must install asks more of them.
How can I create my own loyalty program?
Decide what you want customers to do more often, choose a reward they want, and cost the rules before you look at software. Then pick the route that carries those rules: a rented app, an extension on your store, or a custom build. Our guide to running a loyalty programme in South Africa takes each decision in order.
What is the best app for loyalty cards?
If you want to replace a paper stamp card, look for loyalty card software that puts a digital card in the wallet already on your customers’ phones. Loopy Loyalty’s page says its cards work with Apple Wallet and Google Wallet, and staff stamp them with an app. Before you choose, check how many card designs and locations the plan allows.
